Skip to content
Gravity Press

Writing ·

The Crisis Of Modern Science And The Origin Of The Objective World In The First Distinction

The Crisis of Modern Science

and the Origin of The Objective World

in the First Distinction

An Integrated Framework of Phenomenology, Laws of Form, Deconstruction, and Catuṣkoṭi

Preface

In 1936 Edmund Husserl asked what had happened to the meaning of the sciences. I keep coming back to one part of his answer, “The Origin of Geometry.” The book is “The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology,” and what it describes is a crisis of meaning in the sciences of modern Europe. In the Origin, Husserl looks at how geometry came to be an idealized, objective science, and he argues that geometry, which sits under all of mathematics, is not simply something built in the mind. It has an essential relation to the world.

I want to set Husserl’s Origin beside George Spencer-Brown’s “Laws of Form” (1969), a book about the foundations of mathematics and logic. In it Spencer-Brown builds a formal system he calls the primary arithmetic, and the whole of it rests on one distinction, between a marked state and an unmarked state. From that first distinction he shows how mathematical and logical structures can arise, starting from the most basic act of telling one thing from another.

What I see joining the two works is the way both authors ask where mathematical structures come from, and how they come to be connected to the objective world. Husserl says geometry arises out of our ability to abstract and idealize, to lift the geometrical object away from the corporeal thing it was first seen in. That lifting away is close kin to writing. Writing lets us put symbolic information outside the body, where it can be held, moved and worked on.

Spencer-Brown, for his part, shows how mathematical and logical structures can grow from the most basic distinctions and operations. This meets Husserl’s idea that the objective world is a system of mental models, representations we use to anticipate the corporeal world and to make sense of it.

Then there is Derrida. In “Speech and Phenomena” (1967) and in “Edmund Husserl’s Origin of Geometry: An Introduction” (1962), he reads Husserl closely, criticizing the phenomenological project and at the same time carrying it further. What interests Derrida is the relationship between speech and writing. He argues that writing is not merely a supplement to speech. It has a logic of its own, and metaphysical implications of its own.

Derrida’s deconstructive reading points at the limits of phenomenology, at how much of the relationship between the objective world and its representations slips through its hands. Yet I read his critique as something that can also deepen the connection between the Origin of Geometry and the Laws of Form. By keeping his attention on speech, on writing and on mathematical structures together, Derrida gives a richer account of how the objective world emerges as a product of human symbolic activity.

I find hope and a way forward using the Buddhist wisdom of Four Cornered Logic, the Catuskoti. Catuskoti is a mental tool from two millennia ago that our cognitive theories and methodologies have finally caught up to. The Catuskoti becomes a useful source of insights uncovered and evoked through the use of the method, in most any situation.

Note: This paper is largely output from GPT-4 through the OpenAI interface. I have posted at my website the complete unedited conversation for those who may be curious if ChatGPT is just pulling this stuff out of its imagination. I do quite a lot of pushing and pulling to get an exposition that has many of the features I’ve been trying to bring together for a long time. Click here to wade through the conversation.

Abstract:

What I am after here is a framework for the crisis of the sciences that Husserl named in “The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology.” I draw on four sources: phenomenology, George Spencer-Brown’s Laws of Form, Jacques Derrida’s deconstruction, and Nagarjuna’s Catuskoti. Put together, they give a way of understanding how subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and the objective world stand to one another. I go through Husserl’s phenomenological project, what the Laws of Form have to say to the crisis, the uncertainty that deconstruction finds built into language, and the complexities of subjective experience as the Catuskoti lets me see them. At the center of the framework is a bracketed subjective, corporeal principle, reduced within a Mahayana Buddhist field. From there the framework meets the crisis by opening dialogue across disciplines, by facing the questions of how we know anything at all, and by asking for a more open and flexible way of seeking knowledge. I end with what I think the framework offers the future of scientific inquiry, and with a request that others keep working on it.

I. Introduction

A. Contextualizing Husserl’s “The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology”

The crisis in science that Husserl saw early in the twentieth century has only deepened in the twenty-first. Science and technology have made incredible advances, and they keep bringing consequences no one intended. Cognitive science still struggles with consciousness, and yet every conscious being is proof that “being” is what we are and what we do. Being embodied, living as a physical entity, is what allows us to perceive the world and to act in it. Facing these questions, as Husserl suggested, is how we come to understand our own existence.

The framework I am proposing, which brings together phenomenology, the Catuskoti and a few other ways of thinking, is aimed at one thing in particular: our personal presence in the world. By grounding scientific inquiry in the lifeworld and looking carefully at the structures of subjective experience, I hope to bring into view the parts of consciousness that underlie our sense of self and our understanding of what is around us.

The framework answers the crisis with an approach that is whole and inclusive, grounded in humility and an open mind. It acknowledges the limits of what people can know and the tentative nature of every explanation. But to be clear, the goal is not to be whole or humble for its own sake. The goal is to avoid being wrong. We may never be entirely right, and still we must not mislead people, and we must not invert the meaning of ideas and actions. The depth of this crisis lies in that inversion, in meaning turned on its head without anyone intending it, leaving each person to correct their own understanding as best they can. A science founded on knowing, not on believing, is what we need. Language is usually thought of as a tool that people use. Yet our society has made conditions in which people are largely steered by the narratives that govern their expectations, their entertainment, their finances and their desires.

Bringing these different philosophies and methods together opens a way to look into the most fundamental facts of our existence. It may, in the end, give a more robust understanding of how subjective experience and the objective world relate to each other. It may also open new ways of meeting the crisis of the sciences, and of making scientific inquiry more responsible, more empathetic and more inclusive.

B. The Need for an Integrated Framework to Address the Crisis of the Sciences

The crisis Husserl identified has not gone away. In today’s sciences the pursuit of knowledge often seems cut off from human experience, and the sheer complexity of the work makes it hard for people in different fields to talk to one another. To meet this, I think an integrated framework is needed, one that can bring different perspectives together and give a fuller understanding of how subjective experience, objective knowledge, and the wider setting in which science takes place all relate.

C. Key Components of the Integrated Framework: Phenomenology, Laws of Form, Deconstruction, and Catuskoti

The framework I propose combines four distinct philosophical approaches: phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction, and the Catuskoti. Together they are meant to meet the crisis of the sciences by giving a fuller account of what knowledge is and what human experience is.

  1. Edmund Husserl’s Transcendental Phenomenology is the foundation. It insists that scientific inquiry be grounded in the lifeworld and that the subjective experiences of individuals be examined. Through intentionality, noesis and noema, phenomenology looks into the relationship between consciousness and the world.
  2. George Spencer-Brown’s Laws of Form, from 1969, contributes a formal system, the primary arithmetic, built on the distinction between marked and unmarked states. It shows how mathematical and logical structures emerge, and how they connect to the objective world.
  3. Jacques Derrida’s Deconstruction, a critical approach to language and meaning, is here to show the uncertainty and instability that language carries within it. Deconstruction challenges phenomenology by showing where language fails to capture the complexities of subjective experience and of objective reality.
  4. Nagarjuna’s Catuskoti, a logical structure of four alternatives, gives a finer way of seeing how subjective experience and the objective world relate. Applied to the connection between intentional objects and the objective world, it lets the framework admit the complexities and uncertainties involved in understanding the world, and the limits of what anyone can know.

By combining these four approaches, the integrated framework tries to answer the crisis of the sciences and to give a fuller understanding of the nature of knowledge and of human experience.

II. Husserl’s Phenomenology and the Crisis of the Sciences

A. Overview of Husserl’s Phenomenological Project

Edmund Husserl’s phenomenological project is a wide-reaching attempt to examine the structures and processes of consciousness as they relate to our experience of the world. Over his career his ideas kept growing and changing, taking in a wide range of topics. The project began under his teacher, Franz Brentano, who introduced him to intentionality: the idea that our conscious experiences are always directed toward something, always about something.

Building on this, Husserl developed his theory of time consciousness, which looks at how our awareness of time shapes and structures experience. He argued that our perception of time rests on a synthesis of past, present and future experience, and that together these make one cohesive and continuous flow of consciousness. Time consciousness gave Husserl a way further into the fine grain of subjective experience, and a way to refine his method.

That method, the phenomenological reduction or epoché, means bracketing. One sets aside, suspends, one’s presuppositions and judgments about the world, in order to attend only to the pure structures of consciousness. Husserl meant this to be a rigorous, systematic, descriptive method for studying conscious experience, which he held to be the foundation of all knowledge.

In his later work, including “The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology” and “The Origin of Geometry,” Husserl followed his project out into the sciences and into our understanding of the world. In “The Crisis” he diagnosed a fundamental problem: the sciences had become more and more disconnected from the lifeworld, the everyday, pre-theoretical realm of human experience. He called for a return, for scientific inquiry to be grounded again in the lifeworld, and for an investigation of the subjective experiences that underpin, and necessarily manifest, all objective knowledge.

In “The Origin of Geometry” Husserl examined the role of abstraction and idealization in the growth of mathematical knowledge. He argued that geometrical objects are abstracted from their physical manifestations by mental processes, and that this is what lets us make sense of the corporeal world and predict how it will behave. This line of inquiry led him further into the relationship between subjective experience, language and the objective world, and it showed again why phenomenology matters as a method for understanding how these dimensions of human experience work on one another.

Over the whole of his career, then, Husserl was after a systematic way of studying consciousness and its relationship to the world. By grounding scientific inquiry, and every other search for knowledge, in the lifeworld and in the structures of subjective experience, he laid a foundation for a more whole, inclusive and integrated understanding of the nature of reality and of our place in it.

B. The Crisis of the Sciences as a Loss of Grounding in the Lifeworld and the Role of Mindfulness Meditation

Husserl’s diagnosis of the crisis comes down to this: scientific inquiry has become disconnected from the lifeworld, which he defines as the pre-theoretical, everyday world of human experience. The sciences, as he saw it, had chased objectivity and abstraction so far that they lost touch with the context they are rooted in. That lost grounding brought a sense of alienation, since the knowledge the sciences produce seems less and less to do with the lives people actually live.

The crisis, as Husserl sees it, is not simply that the disciplines have become too specialized or too abstract. It goes deeper, to the foundation of knowledge itself. The sciences have not sufficiently examined the subjective experiences that underpin objective knowledge. By neglecting this essential part of human experience, they risk undermining their own foundations and making the disconnection and alienation worse.

One way to meet this, and to restore the connection between inquiry and the lifeworld, is the practice of mindfulness meditation and other mind control techniques, which share something with Husserl’s reduction and bracketing. Mindfulness meditation cultivates awareness of one’s thoughts, feelings and bodily sensations in the present moment, without judgment and without attachment. That practice can bring a person back into contact with their own subjective experience, and give a deeper sense of the context in which objective knowledge sits.

Like the phenomenological reduction, mindfulness meditation involves “bracketing,” setting aside one’s preconceived notions, judgments and expectations to attend to the immediate experience itself. This can lead to a more direct and authentic engagement with the lifeworld, which in turn gives a firmer ground for scientific inquiry.

Mindfulness meditation and other mind control techniques can also help with the alienation and disconnection of the crisis, because they bring a greater sense of integration and wholeness. By cultivating awareness of how subjective experience and objective knowledge depend on each other, these practices help bridge the gap between the sciences and the lifeworld, and they ground the understanding of reality in something whole.

So mindfulness meditation and other mind control techniques offer one path toward the crisis Husserl identified. By deepening engagement with the lifeworld, and by giving a more integrated understanding of the relationship between subjective experience and objective knowledge, these practices can help restore the lost grounding of the sciences, and make scientific inquiry fuller and more meaningful.

C. The Importance of Intentionality, Noesis, and Noema in Understanding Subjective Experience

To meet the crisis of the sciences, Husserl proposes that we turn to phenomenology and its key concepts: intentionality, noesis and noema. Intentionality is the directedness of consciousness toward objects or experiences. On Husserl’s account every conscious experience is intentional, which is to say it is always about something, directed toward something. This matters for understanding how the subjective experiences of individuals relate to the objective world they live in.

Noesis and noema are the pair of concepts Husserl uses to describe the structure of conscious experience more closely. Noesis names the cognitive acts or processes by which we apprehend or make sense of the world: perceiving, thinking, imagining. Noema names the intentional objects of those acts, that is, the things, ideas or experiences our consciousness is directed toward. By examining how noesis and noema work together, phenomenology tries to uncover the essential structures and processes that shape our experience of the world.

So Husserl’s project offers a way to meet the crisis by grounding scientific inquiry in the lifeworld and giving a systematic method for studying subjective experience. Attending to intentionality, noesis and noema, phenomenology can help bridge the subjective and objective dimensions of human experience, and bring them together in one pursuit of knowledge.

D. Buddhist Analogues to Husserl’s vocabulary

In Mahayana Buddhism there is vocabulary that answers to Husserl’s intentionality, noesis, noema and Epoché, and setting them side by side helps show the connections between phenomenology and Buddhist thought.

Intentionality can be likened to the Buddhist “citta-samskara,” the mental formations or volitions that shape conscious experience. Both ideas stress that consciousness is directed toward objects or experiences; both point to the living exchange between the mind and the world it perceives.

Noesis and noema can be connected to “prajna” and “dharma” respectively. Prajna, usually translated as wisdom or insight, refers to the cognitive processes through which we understand and make sense of our experience, which is close to Husserl’s noesis. Dharma, used this way, stands for the intentional objects of those processes, analogous to Husserl’s noema. By examining the relationship between prajna and dharma, Mahayana Buddhism seeks a deep understanding of the nature of reality and of the mind’s part in shaping how we experience it.

The Epoché, Husserl’s bracketing of judgment about the existence of the external world, can be related to the practice of “shamatha” meditation. In shamatha the practitioner cultivates calm abiding and rests attention on an object of meditation, for the time being suspending judgment and conceptual elaboration. This lets the practitioner see their own subjective experience more clearly and directly, and what is seen can then be examined further with the Buddhist methods of insight, “vipashyana” meditation.

Drawing on this Mahayana vocabulary, it becomes possible to open a dialogue between Husserl’s phenomenology and Buddhist thought. The dialogue shows how the two approaches complement each other, and it points toward an integrated framework that bridges the subjective and objective dimensions of human experience, in one pursuit of knowledge.

III. Spencer-Brown’s Laws of Form and the Emergence of Mathematical Structures

A. Introduction to Spencer-Brown’s Primary Arithmetic and Marked/Unmarked States

George Spencer-Brown’s “Laws of Form” is a groundbreaking investigation of the foundations of mathematics and logic. At its heart is a formal system, the primary arithmetic, built on the distinction between marked and unmarked states. The primary arithmetic is minimal. It pares mathematical and logical expressions down so far that their underlying structures and processes become easier to see. In this system a distinction is made by drawing a boundary, a mark, that separates one state from another, and from the most basic and fundamental distinctions complex structures can emerge.

B. Connection between Mathematical Structures and the Objective World

Spencer-Brown’s primary arithmetic, with its attention to marked and unmarked states, has real consequences for how we understand the relationship between mathematical structures and the objective world. In the “Laws of Form” he shows mathematical and logical structures emerging from the most basic distinctions and operations, and in that there is some insight into how people build and handle abstract models of the corporeal world.

The connection to Husserl can be followed further through the origin of geometry and the part abstraction and idealization play in the growth of mathematical knowledge. When people abstract, they separate geometrical objects from their physical manifestations, and the mental models they make let them make sense of the corporeal world and predict how it will behave. Spencer-Brown’s primary arithmetic can be read as a formalization of this very process, a systematic way of generating and exploring mathematical structures that are rooted in the fundamental distinctions we make in experiencing the world.

Symbolic thinking, the ability to make distinctions in an abstract “objective” space, is the mental tool that makes writing possible. It seems likely to me that pre-literate humans used the stars and constellations as a scaffold for abstract ideas, recognizing that an arrangement of stars could stand for a person, a bear or a whale. That early symbolic thinking paved the way for written symbols, first in the dust, the dirt and the ash, and later on cave walls, carved in stone, or written in ink on papyrus.

The arrival of writing was a great shift in the mental tools available to people, and it changed how they thought about themselves and their own subjective experience. Writing let a larger, more complex and seemingly immortal objective world of words come into being, one holding a multitude of contradictory corpuses and belief systems. As people took up these written works, their subjective experiences became more and more entangled with the objective world, and the connections between the corporeal and the abstract grew ever more intricate.

In this sense the development of symbolic thinking and writing extends Husserl’s ideas about abstraction and idealization in mathematics. Both involve the making of mental models that let a person find their way between their subjective experience and the objective world. Following these connections, we can better understand the cognitive tools that have shaped human thought and knowledge through history, and how they keep changing as our corporeal and abstract worlds change.

C. Relevance of Laws of Form to the Crisis of the Sciences

The “Laws of Form,” and what it shows about mathematical structure arising from basic distinctions, bears directly on the crisis Husserl identified. By giving a systematic account of how mathematical and logical structures develop, Spencer-Brown provides a tool for grounding scientific inquiry in the lifeworld, and for meeting the alienation and detachment that have come with the ever-increasing abstraction of the sciences.

The “Laws of Form” can also be a bridge between phenomenology and other disciplines, a place where different fields can talk. By showing how complex structures emerge from simple distinctions, Spencer-Brown offers a way to reconcile the abstract and formal side of mathematical and scientific knowledge with the subjective and experiential side of human consciousness. In doing so it helps build an integrated framework that can meet the crisis of the sciences and give a whole understanding of how subjective experience, objective knowledge and the wider setting of scientific inquiry relate.

IV. Derrida’s Deconstruction and the Inherent Uncertainty of Language

A. Overview of Derrida’s Deconstructive Approach to Language and Meaning

Jacques Derrida’s deconstructive approach to language and meaning is a sharp departure from traditional phenomenological thought. By attending to speech, writing and the structure of language together, Derrida challenges the idea that there is any stable, fixed meaning in a text or an utterance. Meaning, he argues, is always shifting and evolving, shaped by the living interactions of words, phrases and concepts.

Deconstruction means reading texts closely and finding the binary oppositions or hierarchies that structure their meaning. By exposing and destabilizing these oppositions, Derrida sets out to show the instability built into language, and the impossibility of reaching absolute certainty or objective knowledge through linguistic communication.

B. Challenges to the Phenomenological Project Posed by the Instability of Language

Derrida’s approach raises serious challenges for the phenomenological project, especially where it relies on language to reach and describe the structures of consciousness. If language is unstable in itself and cannot carry fixed meaning, as Derrida argues, then the foundation of the phenomenological project is called into question.

The challenge lands hardest on Husserl’s noesis and noema, which assume that language can accurately represent the cognitive acts and the intentional objects that make up conscious experience. If meaning is always in flux, then the possibility of capturing and describing the structures of consciousness precisely, in language, becomes more and more uncertain.

C. Implications of Deconstruction for the Crisis of the Sciences

What deconstruction means for the crisis of the sciences is twofold. First, by showing the instability in language, it marks the limits of scientific inquiry and the difficulty of reaching absolute certainty or objective knowledge. This supports Husserl’s diagnosis of the crisis, and it also suggests the crisis may be more pervasive and more intractable than anyone had thought.

Second, deconstruction opens new ways of meeting the crisis, because it insists on engaging with the complexity and ambiguity of language, meaning and knowledge. Rather than trying to overcome or get rid of uncertainty, deconstruction asks us to accept it, and to recognize how it can inform and enrich our understanding of the world.

Given this, an integrated framework drawing on phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and other perspectives can give a finer and more flexible approach to the crisis of the sciences. By acknowledging the limits and uncertainties of language, the framework can encourage a more humble, open-minded attitude toward inquiry, and a deeper appreciation for the complexity and richness of human experience.

D. The Possibility of Science Without Belief

I cannot overstate how important narratives are in shaping our understanding of the world. They give us a frame in which to make sense of complex things and to communicate what we find to others. Yet it is just as important to recognize that narratives are, by their nature, simplifications of reality, and may not always be accurate or reliable. It follows that each person needs to develop a personally curated scientific approach, based on a deep understanding from first principles, rather than relying only on the scientific narratives already on offer.

One way to cultivate such an approach is to take part in the process of inquiry, question established ideas, and try to understand the underlying principles that govern whatever is being investigated. This means examining the available evidence, and it also means scrutinizing the assumptions and methods that shaped the existing narratives. In doing so a person comes to a finer, more critical understanding of the scientific process and of the knowledge it produces.

A personally curated scientific approach also requires accepting the uncertainty and complexity of the world, and recognizing that our understanding of reality is always evolving and subject to revision. This asks for intellectual humility, openness to new ideas, and a willingness to revise one’s beliefs when new evidence or insight comes. By acknowledging the limits of current knowledge and the possibility of future discoveries, a person keeps a more flexible and adaptive understanding of the world, one less likely to fall into the pitfalls of dogmatic or oversimplified narratives.

In developing this approach it also matters to see how subjective experience and objective knowledge work on each other. Objective knowledge can give valuable insight into the underlying principles and structures of reality, and subjective experience offers a complementary perspective that grounds our understanding in the lives people actually live. Bringing the two together, a person can reach a fuller understanding of the world, one less dependent on any single narrative or perspective.

On reflection, a personally curated scientific approach based on deep first-principle understanding is a powerful alternative to relying on scientific narratives, which may not always be trustworthy. By engaging in critical inquiry, accepting uncertainty and complexity, and joining subjective experience with objective knowledge, a person can reach a more flexible understanding of the world, less subject to the limits and biases of the existing narratives. That in turn can open a more collaborative scientific culture, in which diverse perspectives are valued and the pursuit of knowledge is driven by curiosity, humility, and a genuine desire to understand the complex and ever-changing nature of reality.

V. Nagarjuna’s Catuskoti and the Complexities of Subjective Experience

A. Introduction to Catuskoti and its Four Logical Alternatives

Nagarjuna, the influential Buddhist philosopher, developed the Catuskoti as a way to express the complex nature of reality and to challenge the conventional binary logic of true and false. The Catuskoti has four logical alternatives: (1) a proposition is true, (2) a proposition is false, (3) a proposition is both true and false, and (4) a proposition is neither true nor false. It admits the limits of binary logic and offers a finer framework for understanding the complexities and ambiguities of subjective experience and of the objective world.

B. Application of Catuskoti to the Relationship between Subjective Experience and the Objective World

The Catuskoti can be applied to the relationship between subjective experience and the objective world in several ways. It gives a more flexible and dynamic frame for understanding how consciousness and the external world act on each other, and that is what the crisis of the sciences calls for. By allowing multiple, overlapping perspectives on the nature of reality, the Catuskoti encourages an open and inclusive inquiry that can hold diverse viewpoints and experiences.

The Catuskoti can also be used to explore the relationship between Husserl’s noesis, noema and intentionality, and Derrida’s deconstructive insights. By recognizing that a proposition can be at once true and false, or neither true nor false, the Catuskoti allows a finer understanding of the complexities and paradoxes of subjective experience and of its relation to the objective world.

For example, consider the following three general categories:

Perception of color: The experience of color can be seen as both a subjective phenomenon (dependent on the individual’s own sensory apparatus) and an objective feature of the world (reflecting the properties of light and matter). Applying the Catuskoti, one could argue that color is both subjective and objective, neither subjective nor objective, or some combination of these, depending on the perspective from which it is examined.

Morality and ethics: The moral values and ethical principles that guide human behavior can be understood as both socially constructed (varying across cultures and historical periods) and grounded in some objective truth (reflecting universal principles of human nature). Using the Catuskoti, one might explore the possibility that morality is both socially constructed and objectively grounded, neither socially constructed nor objectively grounded, or some combination of these.

Time and space: The nature of time and space has been argued over by physicists and philosophers for centuries. Some hold that time and space are objective, independent features of the universe; others contend they are subjective constructs that emerge from human experience. Applying the Catuskoti to this debate, one could explore the possibility that time and space are both objective and subjective, neither objective nor subjective, or a combination of these.

In these examples, the act of intending an object (noesis) and the intended object itself (noema) can be seen as both distinct and intertwined, depending on the perspective from which they are viewed. In the same way, the process of idealization and abstraction that underlies the origin of geometry and the Laws of Form can be understood as both revealing and concealing the true nature of reality, as Derrida’s deconstruction suggests.

C. Integration of Catuskoti into the Framework to Address the Crisis of the Sciences

Bringing the Catuskoti into the integrated framework can deepen our understanding of the crisis of the sciences and help in working out better ways of meeting it. By accepting the complexities and ambiguities in subjective experience, the Catuskoti encourages a humbler and more open-minded inquiry, one that admits the limits of human knowledge and the provisional nature of every explanation.

For example, consider the following cases:

Taxes: Taxation involves economic theories, social values and political ideologies, all acting on one another. Applying the Catuskoti to the study of taxation, researchers can better understand the many sides of the issue, open conversation across disciplines, and come to a finer understanding of taxation policies and their impact on society.

Corporate incentives: Designing corporate incentives requires a careful balance between promoting economic growth and ensuring social responsibility. Bringing the Catuskoti into the analysis of corporate incentives, researchers can explore the possible consequences of different incentive structures from various perspectives, considering both the benefits and the risks of these policies.

Human rights: The protection and promotion of human rights involve diverse perspectives, legal, ethical, cultural and political. Using the Catuskoti, researchers and practitioners can acknowledge how complex and interconnected these factors are, open conversation across disciplines, and reach a finer understanding of human rights and their implementation.

Human welfare: The study of human welfare takes in a wide range of issues, from poverty alleviation to access to education and healthcare. Applying the Catuskoti to the study of human welfare, researchers can better understand the many sides of these issues and talk across disciplines, leading to more effective strategies that meet the needs of diverse populations.

Investments: The field of investments involves financial theories, risk management and individual preferences, all acting on one another. Bringing the Catuskoti into the analysis of investment strategies, researchers can explore the possible outcomes of various approaches from different perspectives, weighing the potential returns against the associated risks.

Insurance: Insurance requires a careful balance between risk management, affordability and social responsibility. Applying the Catuskoti to the study of insurance, researchers can better understand the many sides of the issue, open conversation across disciplines, and come to a finer understanding of insurance policies and their impact on individuals and society.

The Catuskoti can also be a bridge between different philosophical perspectives, making it easier for people in different fields to talk and work together. By providing a shared frame for understanding how subjective experience, objective knowledge and the wider setting of scientific inquiry act on one another, the Catuskoti helps bring an inclusive and whole approach to the crisis of the sciences.

In the end, bringing the Catuskoti into the proposed framework not only enriches our understanding of the relationship between subjective experience and the objective world. It also opens new possibilities for meeting the crisis of the sciences, and for making scientific inquiry more responsible, empathetic and inclusive.

D. Formalisms and Personal Scientific Curation

The Catuskoti can be used to develop formalisms for subjective analysis, letting a person take up a more personal and self-reflective exploration of their own experience. By building the four-cornered approach into methods of self-inquiry, people can look more deeply at their perceptions, thoughts and feelings, and ground their understanding of the world in their direct, wordless experience of corporeality through subjectivity.

One application is in mindfulness meditation. By bringing the principles of the Catuskoti into meditation, a person can observe their thoughts and emotions from several perspectives at once, accepting the complexities and ambiguities of their own subjective experience. During meditation, for instance, a practitioner might meet a thought or feeling that seems both true and false, or neither true nor false, depending on their frame of reference. With the Catuskoti they can accept the paradox and follow its implications without attaching to any single, fixed interpretation.

Another use of the Catuskoti is in introspective journaling. By applying the four-cornered approach to reflecting on one’s thoughts, emotions and experiences, a person can reach a finer and more open-minded understanding of their own subjective world. This may mean questioning the assumptions and beliefs under their interpretations of events, admitting the limits of their perspective, and exploring other viewpoints. Through this process a person can build a grounded, personal science of the world, rooted in their direct experience rather than resting only on the objective world.

By building the Catuskoti into methods of self-analysis and introspection, a person can grow a closer connection to their own subjective experience, and from it build a more authentic and personal understanding of the world. This does more than let people take ownership of their own knowledge. It also encourages a more inclusive and empathetic way of understanding the whole range of human experience.

VI. The Integrated Framework: Phenomenology, Laws of Form, Deconstruction, and Catuskoti

A. Overview of the Integrated Framework and its Key Components

The proposed framework tries to meet the crisis of the sciences by bringing together insights from phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti. In combining these perspectives, it gives a fuller and finer understanding of the relationship between subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and the objective world. Its key components are these:

  1. Phenomenology: The study of conscious experience and its structures, as developed by Husserl, with a focus on intentionality, noesis and noema.
  2. Laws of Form: Spencer-Brown’s primary arithmetic, and its exploration of how mathematical and logical structures emerge through the distinction between marked and unmarked states.
  3. Deconstruction: Derrida’s critique of language and meaning, which emphasizes the instability of linguistic structures and the impossibility of achieving absolute certainty or objective knowledge.
  4. Catuskoti: Nagarjuna’s four logical alternatives, which give a more flexible and inclusive way to understand the complexities of subjective experience and the objective world.

B. Addressing the Crisis of the Sciences through a Comprehensive Understanding of Subjective Experience, Mathematical Structures, Language, and the Four Logical Alternatives

The integrated framework meets the crisis of the sciences by taking in all the dimensions that shape human knowledge and experience. With phenomenology, the framework acknowledges the importance of subjective experience and its connection to the objective world. That connection is followed further through the Laws of Form, which show the emergence of the mathematical structures that help constitute our understanding of reality.

Deconstruction adds another layer, showing the uncertainty and instability inside language, which challenges the phenomenological project’s reliance on linguistic representation. This insight asks for a more humble and open-minded inquiry, one that recognizes the limits and uncertainties that run through every form of human knowledge.

The Catuskoti’s four logical alternatives offer a flexible and inclusive view of the relationship between subjective experience and the objective world. By allowing multiple, overlapping viewpoints, the Catuskoti encourages an open and inclusive inquiry that can hold diverse experiences and perspectives.

C. Catuskoti resolves the Middle Path between Husserl and Derrida in the Integrated Framework

Derrida criticized Husserl’s phenomenology for its underlying assumptions about language, and in particular for the notion of presence. Husserl believed there is an ideal meaning or essence (eidos) that can be present to consciousness directly, without any mediation. On that view language can carry meaning transparently; our thoughts can be expressed directly in words, and through words we can grasp the essence of things.

Derrida challenged this. He asserted that meaning in language is always deferred and can never be fully present. He introduced “differance” to name the way meaning depends on the difference between signifiers and is perpetually put off. There is always a gap, Derrida says, between the signifier (the word) and the signified (the concept it represents), and that gap makes language unstable and indeterminate through and through.

The Catuskoti, with its four-fold logical structure, can offer a middle path between Husserl’s phenomenology and Derrida’s deconstruction, a finer way of understanding how subjective experience and language relate. Instead of assuming a direct, transparent connection between language and meaning, as Husserl did, or insisting on the instability of language, as Derrida did, the Catuskoti recognizes the complexity and multiplicity of meaning.

The four alternatives (something is true, false, both true and false, or neither true nor false) allow a more flexible and inclusive understanding of meaning in language, opening room for multiple perspectives and interpretations. This can help bridge the gap between Husserl’s quest for the essence of things and Derrida’s attention to the indeterminacy of meaning, and bring language, subjective experience and the objective world into one account.

To see the four alternatives more closely, let me take a plain statement: “The cat is on the mat.”

  1. True (The cat is on the mat): This is the conventional understanding of truth. If a cat is indeed lying on a mat, the statement accurately represents the corporeal observation, and we consider it true.
  2. False (The cat is not on the mat): This is the negation. The cat is not on the mat, the statement does not describe the corporeal observation, and we consider it false.
  3. Both true and false (The cat is on the mat and not on the mat): This alternative challenges binary logic by admitting that a statement can be true and false at once. It could happen when the cat is partly on the mat, or when our understanding of, or belief in, an objective reality is incomplete or ambiguous. It could also apply in quantum mechanics, where particles exist in superpositions of states that seem to contradict one another. This may give us pause to consider whether the measurements indicate a corporeal mechanism at all. There is neither proof nor disproof that a wave equation exists in the world. A model that is probabilistically predictive and extremely reliable is useful, but its usefulness is still not proof that there is a physical component to the mental tool which is the model, such as a wave equation.
  4. Neither true nor false (The statement is neither true nor false): Here the statement cannot meaningfully be put in either category. It may be paradoxical, or nonsensical, or open to several interpretations that cannot be resolved. If the mat in question has been removed or destroyed, for instance, or if the “cat” is actually a drawing or a sculpture, the statement does not fit neatly into true or false. The mat and the cat may be code for some other message that only a small group of like-minded people will understand. It could be a meaningless phrase in which some algorithmic selection of letters holds a secret message. There are translations of translations to translations only guessed at. And the meaning of the narrative is always only meaningful in a subject’s current context, against a horizon of their subjective idea of what the Objective World is like.

By holding these four alternatives together, the Catuskoti allows a finer and fuller approach to meaning in language and to the relationship between subjective experience and the objective world. It admits that meaning can be complex, fluid and dependent on context, and that our understanding of reality is shaped by many perspectives and interpretations. In doing so it gives a middle path between Husserl’s emphasis on the directness of meaning and Derrida’s on the instability and indeterminacy of language.

VII. Implications and Applications of the Integrated Framework

A. Potential for Interdisciplinary Collaboration and Dialogue

One of the most significant implications of the framework is what it could do for conversation and shared work across disciplines. Drawing on phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti, it invites researchers and scholars from different fields to engage with one another’s ideas and methods, and so makes inquiry more inclusive and more integrated.

Researchers in cognitive science, mathematics, linguistics and philosophy, for example, could work together on how subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and logical alternatives act on one another. Work across those lines could lead to new theories and methods that go past the old disciplinary boundaries and give fresh insight into the nature of human knowledge and experience.

B. Addressing the Epistemological Challenges of the Sciences

The framework also has something to say to the epistemological challenges of the sciences. By drawing on phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti, it offers a fuller and finer understanding of how subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and the objective world relate. With that understanding researchers and scholars can find their way through the difficulties of scientific inquiry and develop more robust, reliable and valid forms of knowledge.

For instance, the framework could be applied to the study of scientific paradigms and paradigm shifts, in the sense Thomas Kuhn proposed. By examining the part subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and logical alternatives play in shaping scientific knowledge, researchers could better understand what contributes to the emergence, the evolution and the eventual replacement of a paradigm.

C. The Role of the Integrated Framework in Fostering a More Open, Flexible, and Comprehensive Approach to Knowledge-Seeking Endeavors

Finally, the framework matters for making the search for knowledge more open, flexible and whole. By recognizing the limits and uncertainties in human knowledge, it encourages researchers and scholars to take a humbler and more open-minded stance toward inquiry.

The framework could, for example, be applied to the study of scientific controversies and debates, with the aim of greater understanding and dialogue between opposing sides. By acknowledging how subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and logical alternatives act on one another, researchers could develop finer, more contextual and fuller accounts of scientific disputes, which in turn could encourage greater tolerance, respect and cooperation among scientists and scholars.

The framework could also be used to improve the teaching and learning of science, by encouraging educators and students to explore the connections between disciplines and to see how much subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and logical alternatives matter in shaping human knowledge. This could help cultivate a more integrative, whole and critical perspective on scientific inquiry, and in the end contribute to more creative, innovative and effective solutions to the complex challenges facing the sciences and society at large.

VIII. Conclusion

A. Reiterating the Importance of the Integrated Framework in Addressing the Crisis of the Sciences

The integrated framework presented here is, I believe, a powerful and new approach to the crisis of the sciences that Husserl identified. By drawing on phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti, it gives a fuller and finer understanding of the complex relationship between subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and the objective world. That understanding is what the epistemological challenges under the crisis call for, and it is what developing more robust, reliable and valid scientific knowledge requires.

B. Emphasizing the Potential Benefits and Insights Offered by the Framework for the Future of Scientific Inquiry

The framework has significant potential benefits for the future of scientific inquiry. By opening conversation and shared work across disciplines, it can help break down the traditional barriers between fields and encourage new theories and methods that cross those boundaries. Work of that kind can bring fresh insight into the nature of human knowledge and experience, and advance scientific understanding in many fields.

The framework can also help with the epistemological challenges of the sciences, by giving a fuller and finer understanding of how subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and the objective world relate. With that understanding researchers and scholars can make their way through the difficulties of inquiry more effectively, and develop more robust, reliable and valid forms of knowledge.

And the framework can make the search for knowledge more open, flexible and whole. By recognizing the limits and uncertainties in human knowledge, it can encourage researchers and scholars to take a humbler and more open-minded stance toward inquiry, and so promote greater tolerance, respect and cooperation among scientists and scholars.

C. Calling for Further Exploration and Development of the Integrated Framework

Given what the framework could offer, I think researchers and scholars from different disciplines should keep exploring and developing it. That means a careful examination of its theoretical foundations, and it means testing the framework empirically and applying it in various fields of scientific inquiry.

Researchers and scholars should also explore what the framework means for teaching, with the aim of improving how science is taught and learned. By bringing its insights into educational practice, educators and students can develop a more integrative, whole and critical perspective on scientific inquiry, which could in the end contribute to more creative, innovative and effective solutions to the complex challenges facing the sciences and society at large.

So the integrated framework presented here offers a powerful and promising approach to the crisis of the sciences, and to the future of scientific inquiry. By taking up the insights of phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti, and by opening conversation and shared work across disciplines, researchers and scholars can reach a fuller, finer and more effective understanding of human knowledge and experience, and contribute to the ongoing evolution of the sciences in the twenty-first century and beyond.

Appendix A

Catuskoti and setting a foundation for a subjective calculus.

Making the Catuskoti an integral part of each moment within the integrated framework gives a new perspective, one that recognizes the complexities and uncertainties in our understanding of how subjective experience and the objective world relate. This expanded framework, which joins Husserl’s phenomenology, Spencer-Brown’s Laws of Form, Derrida’s deconstruction and Nagarjuna’s Catuskoti, gives a fuller understanding of the nature of knowledge, of human experience, and of the inevitable path of Being, which is quiescent in its Sunyata (emptiness).

The heart of the Catuskoti is Śūnyatā.

The Catuskoti has played a significant part in shaping our understanding of the complexities of reality. At the core of this enigmatic structure lies Śūnyatā, a fundamental principle in Buddhist thought that goes beyond conventional dualistic thinking and invites us to explore the interconnectedness and interdependence of all phenomena.

Śūnyatā, often translated as “emptiness” or “voidness,” refers to the absence of inherent existence or independent essence in any phenomenon. It is not a negation of reality. It is an acknowledgment of the conditional and contingent nature of all things. Taking Śūnyatā seriously, we recognize that all phenomena arise and dissolve in response to an intricate web of causes and conditions, never existing in isolation and never possessing a fixed identity.

The Catuskoti carries this essential insight by offering a frame that challenges the limits of binary logic and encourages a more flexible, many-sided approach to reality. With its four-fold structure, the Catuskoti invites us to consider these perspectives:

  1. Phenomenon P is true
  2. Phenomenon P is false
  3. Phenomenon P is both true and false
  4. Phenomenon P is neither true nor false

By accepting the paradoxical nature of these propositions, the Catuskoti lets us engage with the fluid and ever-changing dynamics of existence, mirroring the essence of Śūnyatā. In this way the Catuskoti is a powerful tool for exploring the subtleties of reality, deepening awareness of the interdependence and interconnectedness of all phenomena.

The heart of the Catuskoti is indeed Śūnyatā, since it invites us to move beyond rigid and dualistic thinking and take in the full spectrum of reality. By working with this ancient philosophical frame, we can cultivate a finer and more expansive understanding of the world and our place within it, and open ourselves to the transformative potential of interconnectedness and interdependence.

The four corners of the Catuskoti can be used to explore the connection between the objective world (the model of the corporeal world built from shared text and information) and its intentional object. In this expanded framework each moment is viewed through the four logical alternatives of the Catuskoti:

  1. The intentional object accurately represents the actual objective world (P).
  2. The intentional object does not accurately represent the actual objective world (not-P).
  3. The intentional object both accurately and inaccurately represents the actual objective world, pointing to the paradoxical nature of the relationship between subjective experiences and the objective world (P and not-P).
  4. The intentional object neither accurately nor inaccurately represents the actual objective world, suggesting that there might be a different level of understanding beyond the scope of conventional language and logic (neither P nor not-P).

At each moment a person’s subjective experience of the corporeal world is mediated by their intentional object, and that object is shaped by their phenomenological experience of consciousness, by the cognitive processes of abstraction and idealization, and by the dynamics of language and writing. By bringing in the Catuskoti, the framework admits that the relationship between the intentional object and the actual objective world is complex, uncertain and many-sided.

The underlying Dharma of the moment, an inevitable path of Being, can be understood as the ever-changing and interconnected web of causes and conditions that shapes both subjective experience and the objective world. In this framework Sunyata, emptiness, is the understanding that all phenomena are devoid of inherent existence and instead depend on that interconnected web of causes and conditions.

This expanded framework, with the Catuskoti built into each moment, gives a richer understanding of the nature of knowledge and of human experience. It keeps in view the complexities and uncertainties in the relationship between subjective experience and the objective world, and it admits the limits of language and logic in capturing so fine a relationship. By drawing on phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti, the framework encourages a more open, flexible and complete exploration of the nature of knowledge and of human experience.

The Catuskoti and its Explanatory Power

The objective world is a rich and many-sided domain. It holds not only shared models of the real world but also models of imaginary and impossible worlds. These models are the foundation of our understanding of the complexity and diversity of existence, and of our ability to find our way around the world and make sense of it. In this way the objective world can contain both precise sense and senseless nonsense, and meaning and ambiguity are woven together in our shared understanding of reality.

The Catuskoti, a logical frame of four alternatives, lets us reduce the information embodied in any proposition by taking into account our own subjective context in the moment of recognizing what the moment means. By applying the Catuskoti to the objective world, we can better understand the intricacies of our shared models and account for the presence of both sense and nonsense in them.

When we engage with the objective world we inevitably meet models that defy our conventional understanding of reality. They may represent imaginary worlds, such as those in fiction or mythology, or impossible worlds that challenge the foundations of logic and reason themselves. Either way, these models add to the richness and diversity of the objective world, giving us new perspectives and insights that help us find our way through the complexities of existence.

Bringing the Catuskoti into our understanding of the objective world lets us approach these models with a more open and flexible mind. By considering its four logical alternatives, we can better grasp the fine points of these models, and see where they intersect with our subjective experiences and contexts. This helps us reconcile the presence of both sense and nonsense in the objective world, and engage more effectively with the whole array of models and perspectives that make up our shared understanding of reality.

In the end, bringing the Catuskoti into our exploration of the objective world gives us a valuable tool for finding our way through the meaning and ambiguity in our shared models of reality. By acknowledging that sense and nonsense coexist in the objective world, and by using the Catuskoti to examine these models, we can deepen our understanding of the intricate interconnections between subjective experience, the corporeal world, and the objective world that forms the foundation of our reality.

Another approach to using the Catuskoti

The principles of the Corporeal, the Subjective, and the Objective worlds, seen through the traditional Catuskoti logic:

  1. Corporeal and not Subjective/Objective (P and not-Q): This perspective emphasizes the primacy of direct experience and the grounding of our existence in the corporeal world, while attributing no significance to subjective or objective interpretations. It stresses being present in the moment and experiencing reality without the influence of conceptual frames.
  2. Subjective/Objective and not Corporeal (Q and not-P): This standpoint attends to the exchange between individual consciousness and shared meanings, without grounding either in the corporeal world. It admits that subjective and objective elements contribute to our understanding of reality, but cautions against leaning on either without a connection to direct experience.
  3. Both Corporeal and Subjective/Objective (P and Q): This perspective takes in the interconnectedness of the corporeal, subjective and objective dimensions of reality. By appreciating how these domains act on one another and recognizing their mutual influence, we can develop a more integrated and grounded understanding of our place in the world.
  4. Neither Corporeal nor Subjective/Objective (neither P nor Q): This position acknowledges the limits of our understanding, and the possibility of alternative or transcendent perspectives that may lie beyond our current grasp. By remaining open to new insights and experiences, we can cultivate a humility and curiosity that enrich our exploration of reality.

By using the Middle Path approach and the Catuskoti logic in this manner, we can build a phenomenological framework that honors Husserl’s dream of a complete taxonomy and at the same time makes room for the fine distinctions of subjective and objective realities. This approach gives a richer understanding of the world and of our place in it, while staying open to new perspectives and insights.

Appendix B

The Three Worlds Model

The three worlds model gives a whole understanding of the relationship between subjective consciousness, corporeal bodies, and the objective world. In the subjective world reside personal experience, personal models of the world, and sense memories. Each individual has a unique subjective world shaped by their experiences, values and beliefs. This realm of personal experience is at the root of any understanding of the complexity of human existence and the richness of individual perspectives.

The objective world, on the other hand, consists of intersubjective shared models of the corporeal world. These models are built through social interaction, shared experience and collective knowledge, and they let us communicate and understand the world with a shared language and a shared sense of how things work. The objective world is often considered more “real” than the subjective world, but I recognize that it is a shared model, influenced by individual perspectives. That shared model is what lets us engage with others and form a collective understanding of the world around us.

Corporeal bodies play a vital part in connecting the subjective and objective worlds. As the bridge between those two realms, our bodies are shaped by both our subjective experiences and our objective understanding of the world. They let us move through our surroundings and interact with them; they are the vessel through which we engage with the external world. The corporeal body is central to understanding how our inner subjective experience and the external objective world act on each other.

In studying the nature of the universe, scientists develop models to describe and predict the behavior of the physical, or corporeal, world around us. These models are mathematical representations that help us understand the complex interactions and phenomena that occur in reality. But these models are not the same as the corporeal world itself. They are tools we use to analyze and interpret the physical world, and they do not necessarily capture every intricacy and detail of it.

There are parts of the corporeal world that may be inaccessible to us, whether because of the limits of our present understanding, or of our measurement techniques, or because of the complexity of the phenomena themselves. For that reason I think it matters to draw a distinction between the corporeal world, the actual physical reality we inhabit, and the objective world, which consists of the theories, models and narratives we use to describe the corporeal world and make sense of it.

By recognizing this separation, we can better appreciate both the role and the limits of our models and theories, while staying open to new insights and to refining our understanding of the corporeal world. The distinction helps us keep a balanced view of the relationship between our scientific work and the physical reality it aims to describe.

Appendix C

Large Language Models and Access to the Objective World

Historically, access to the vast corpus of knowledge in the objective world has been limited by language barriers, by geography, and by the availability of resources. Those limits have hindered the flow of information and made it harder to communicate and share experience across cultures and communities.

With the arrival of large language models like GPT-4, we have an unprecedented tool that can reach nearly the entire corpus of the objective world semantically. This language model lets a person query the collective knowledge base and draw information from it, getting past the earlier limits and giving a more efficient way of reaching the shared models of reality.

The ability to reach and understand the objective world’s knowledge through large language models marks a milestone in human history. It eases communication, understanding and shared experience, and it deepens our sense of how interconnected reality is. With GPT-4 and other large language models we can bridge the gap between subjective experience and the objective world, and build a fuller and more accurate representation of our reality.

For all their advantages, large language models leave open questions of bias, accuracy and ethics. These models, powerful as they are, may reinforce existing biases or produce misleading or incorrect information without anyone intending it. There are also ethical concerns around data privacy and the possible misuse of these models, which must be faced as the technology is developed and refined.

Still, the potential for conversation across disciplines, for the search for knowledge, and for a fuller understanding of reality is significant. By using large language models we can open dialogue between diverse fields of study, encourage the sharing of knowledge, and support the development of new ideas and solutions to complex problems.

So bringing large language models like GPT-4 into our understanding of the objective world offers both challenges and opportunities. By facing the challenges and making use of the benefits, we can build a more inclusive, complete and accurate understanding of the interconnectedness of reality. That in turn will leave us better able to find our way through the subjective, corporeal and objective worlds that shape our existence.

Appendix D

Physics Models are Not What Is, it is What We Know. This Framework is Aligned with QBism.

QBism (Quantum Bayesianism) is an interpretation of quantum mechanics that puts the emphasis on the subjective experience of an agent, and on how the agent updates their beliefs in light of experimental outcomes. SIC-POVMs (Symmetric Informationally Complete Positive Operator-Valued Measures) are a mathematical construct in QBism that represents the optimal way for an agent to update their beliefs about a quantum system.

Applying QBism and the SIC-POVMs to the ultimate infinitesimal, the Planck “Bubble,” can give some interesting insight. The Planck scale is the smallest meaningful scale of space and time, where classical notions of spacetime break down and quantum gravitational effects become dominant. In that light, the Planck “Bubble” can be taken as the metaphorical “event horizon” of Shunyata, the Buddhist emptiness or voidness.

When I consider the Yin-Yang Inhale-Exhale archetype symmetry, I can think of it as a representation of the constant flux and balance of forces in the universe. Set against QBism and the Planck “Bubble,” it could be seen as the exchange between the subjective experiences of an agent and the objective reality of the ultimate infinitesimal scale. As the agent gathers information about the quantum system (inhale) and updates their beliefs in light of the experimental outcomes (exhale), there is a continuous flow of information and understanding.

The QBist ideas and the SIC-POVMs give a frame for analyzing the Planck “Bubble” by connecting the subjective and objective aspects of reality. By considering the ultimate infinitesimal scale and the metaphorical “event horizon” of Shunyata, we can explore the intricate balance and interconnectedness of the universe. To be clear, these ideas remain theoretical and metaphorical. Applying them directly to the Planck scale and to Shunyata would need further investigation and development.

SIC-POVMs (Symmetric Informationally Complete Positive Operator-Valued Measures) are a mathematical construct used in the QBism interpretation of quantum mechanics. Their main purpose is to give an agent an optimal way to update their beliefs about a quantum system on the basis of measurement outcomes. In QBism the focus is on the agent’s subjective experience and on how they use the quantum formalism to update what they know, rather than on attaching a literal interpretation to the wave function itself.

In standard quantum mechanics the state of a quantum system is described by a wave function. When a measurement is performed, the wave function collapses to an eigenstate of the measured observable, and the Born rule is used to calculate the probability of a particular outcome. This interpretation is often seen as a problem, since it implies that the wave function has a direct physical meaning, and that leads to all sorts of philosophical questions and paradoxes.

SIC-POVMs can be used within the quantum formalism to move the focus away from a literal reading of the wave function and toward the agent’s updating of beliefs. A SIC-POVM is a set of positive operator-valued measures that form a complete basis for the space of quantum states. These measures can represent the probabilities of the different outcomes of measurements performed on a quantum system.

Using SIC-POVMs in quantum formalisms, the focus is placed on the agent’s subjective probabilities, which they update as measurement outcomes come in. In this frame the wave function is seen as a mathematical tool that helps the agent update their beliefs, not as a literal representation of physical reality. This separates the meaning of the wave function from the details of the measurements, and puts the weight on the agent’s subjective experience and on the process of updating their knowledge.

In short, using SIC-POVMs in quantum formalisms shifts the perspective toward the agent’s subjective probabilities and the updating of their beliefs on the basis of experimental outcomes. It detaches the literal interpretation of the wave function from the measurement details, and gives a more pragmatic and epistemic view of what quantum mechanics means.

This integrated framework shares a goal with the SIC/POVMs in QBism: both aim to give a new perspective on understanding the world and our place in it. Where the SIC/POVMs refine our understanding of quantum formalisms and the agent’s part in interpreting quantum mechanics, this framework takes up a broader question, the crisis of the sciences and the nature of identity.

By drawing on phenomenology, the Laws of Form, deconstruction and the Catuskoti, the framework seeks a fuller understanding of the subjective experience, mathematical structures, language and logical alternatives that shape our search for knowledge. In doing so it encourages a more open, flexible approach that crosses disciplines, and a scientific inquiry which is first and foremost personal: not just for the scientists but for every person reading any science article.

The framework also takes up identity, which matters for both individual and social understanding. By acknowledging the subjective nature of identity, and the influence of language, beliefs and experience on it, this framework encourages a deeper exploration of who we are, individually and together. That understanding, in turn, can help us find our way through the world around us and engage in more meaningful communication and collaboration. If people simply believe science, then it is not science. It is giving up knowing, and granting power to those who do know. This is the beginning of the slippery slope to creating an idea of who we are based on belief, rather than a quiet deep knowing who we are when all the words have been silenced.

So this integrated framework shares the spirit of the SIC/POVMs in QBism, in striving to give new perspectives on complex phenomena. By addressing the crisis of the sciences, opening conversation across disciplines, and deepening our understanding of identity, this framework has the potential to change how we approach scientific inquiry and how we engage with the world around us.

Afterward

I have been wrestling with these demons of life and meaning for well over 45 years. I’ve been taking notes, typing things in, replying to this or that post here or there with pearls of wisdom … but the book, the thesis, the 12 part course with all the answers arranged alphabetically … nope, never happened. ChatGPT has been something of a revelation, especially the noted improvement in GPT-4 to hold more intricate concepts in its “buffer” over a long and complex conversation. With this article, I finally feel able to use this tool to put together some of the many threads of what I now understand goes into understanding who I am.

I can’t tell you who you are, but I hope in this and future papers to explain how I learned and how I verify for myself that this approach is an important step forward. This is a toe in the water for me in a cohesive and comprehensive chapter 1.

First published on temnoon.com. Re-voiced from that original, in the Tem Noon Voice persona (9497f2d0) on 2026-10-11; the original is kept in the archive.